The strange case of the fourth-and-a-half floor: the way 3rd-6th-graders cope with the solution of a real-world problem
Tipo de documento
Autores
Lista de autores
Gazit, Avikam
Resumen
Does mathematics aim to develop logical thinking and find original and interesting relations in its various structures, or to serve as an auxiliary aid for solving problems in areas of science, society and daily life? One could say that the debate is senseless since mathematics is designed for both goals. However, teaching it in elementary school does not take the authentic daily component very seriously, in spite of the curriculum statement of intents. The present study investigated how 3rd-6th-grades solve a real-world problem about the middle floor in a 9-floor building and relate to the result their obtained. The highest success percentage was at the 4th-grade and the lowest at the 6th-grade. Nevertheless, the most interesting finding of the study was the pupils' reference to the illogical and unrealistic answer: the fourth-and-a half floor, being the result of 9:2. About half of the 6th-graders and about one third of the 5th-graders gave such answer without any word of criticism about the obtained number. Only about 13%-15% of the 3rd-4th grade pupils gave such an answer. An inevitable conclusion is that the higher the elementary school age group is, the more the learnt mathematics detaches pupils from reality. The pupils do not use logical considerations, solving problems mechanically, without critical reflection. It is recommended dedicating a considerable part of mathematics lessons at elementary school to the solution of real-world day-by-day problems and to processes of reflection about the received answers.
Fecha
2010
Tipo de fecha
Estado publicación
Términos clave
Contextos o situaciones | Estrategias de solución | Lógica matemática | Pensamientos matemáticos | Sociopolíticos
Enfoque
Nivel educativo
Educación primaria, escuela elemental (6 a 12 años) | Educación secundaria básica (12 a 16 años)
Idioma
Revisado por pares
Formato del archivo
Volumen
3
Número
1
Rango páginas (artículo)
25-43
ISSN
21765634
Referencias
Amichay, Y. (1998). Open closed open. Jerusalem: Shoken Publishing. [Hebrew] Asman, D. & Markovits, Z. (2001). The Use of Real World Knowledge in Solving Mathematical Problems, In M. van den Heuvel- Panhuizen, (Ed.), Proceedings of the 25th conference of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, The Netherlands, 2, pp. 65- 72. Boden, M. (1979). Piaget. HarperCollinsPublishers Ltd. Bruer, J. T. (1994). How Children Learn. Executive Educator, 16(8), pp. 32-36. Calaprice, A .(1996). Like Einstein said. Princeton Universit Press Gazit, A. (2003). Carpenter, tractors and microbes for developing mathematical thinking - How do 10th grade students and pre-service teachers solve challenging problems. Paper presented at PME conference, International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education. July 2003. Honolulu, Hawaii. Gravemeijer, K. (1997). Mediating Between Concrete and Abstract, in T. Nunes & P. Bryant (Eds.), Learning and Teaching Mathematics. An International Perspective, Hove, East Sussex: Psychology Press Ltd, pp.315-345. Hogovan, L. (1962). Mathematics for a million. Sifriyat Hapoalim Publishing. [Hebrew] Illich, A. (1973), Elimination of School. Givatayim-Ramat Gan: Massada Publishing. [Hebrew] Jacobs, V. R. and Ambrose, R. C. (2008-2009). Making the most of story problems. Teaching children mathematics. 16(5). pp.260-266. Reston, Virginia: NCTM. McNelis, S. & Dunn, J. A. (1977). Why Teach Mathematics? International Journal of Mathematics Education in Science and Technology, Vol. 8, No 2. Merseth, K. K. (1993). How old is the Shepherd? An Essay about Mathematics Education. Phi Delta Kappan, 74(7), pp 548-584. Ministry of Education and Culture (2007). The new curriculum in mathematics for elementary school. Jerusalem: Ministry of Education and Culture. [Hebrew] National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2000). Principles and Standards for School Mathematics, V.A.: Reston. Nunes, T., Schleimann A. D. and Caharrer, D. W. (1993). Street Mathematics and School Mathematics. New York: Cambridge University Press. Pimm, D. (1987). Speaking Mathematically. London: Rutledge & Kegan Paul. Polya, G. (1957). How to Solve It? Princeton University Press. Polya, G. (1981). Mathematical Discovery: on Understanding, Learning, and Teaching Problem Solving. (combined ed.), N.Y.: Wiley. Resnick, L. B. (1987). Learning in School and Out. Educational Research, 16 (9), pp. 13-20. Russell, B. (1963). The Study of Mathematics. Mysticism and Logic. London: Unwin, pp 48-58. Russell, S. J. (1996). Changing the Elementary Mathematics Curriculum: Obstacles and Changes. http://ra.terc.edu/hub/regional_networks/cia/math/elem-mathcurr.html Sing, S. (1997). Fermat's enigma, Walker and Company. Steen, A. L. (1989). Teaching Mathematics for Tomorrow's World, Educational Leadership, 7(1), pp. 18-22. Unguru, S. (1989), Introduction to the history of mathematics, Part I, Broadcast University, Ministry of Defense. [Hebrew]